CO129-391 - Acting Governor Claud Severn Governor Sir May - 1912 [7-8] — Page 50

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All

don) al homomor? 1. Bas mevod u to contilla 321 30 antolatzo vk.

wal at gootw vino Jon any j1 Towog od orusoed bortevon at vooter o Las mort evo get 30 asw 1. adr oaie sui 、asium mwom-:low nisJ190 vď

xov 1

.18m bas nam neewood agatisob nl nlasɗo bipoda doldw biebuaJa nwora eva: blnow notsawosib delup oldJII -191116 to avutoďtede ensik

9.10 I ..Ilecajun e mi self 9380 ** blat oven I as breysi au mcewood conG Jeric bre doo Jo vtreq-brow s of belêlême ai Jnemarovon erij jsij eergs jxed end at motanto -#-# Indiobloos yns ou notjqsaxe food yens Ti -ning to 9380 vnd mi JBNC JUT ¡Jalager of em das of Deldijne enew voris -alb er or moldaeup s al sard dog .os beidisme son grow yede axorro 3'79

Joo Trequi no baai- to bebloob od of Jen Tennan ylbreitt a ni beaaro

Th dob w Tennsm bobnari-dghi oris at bas moldawrotu) 94BWOOsal bas .bouqobs as♫ rieved

verid datze Jer, I GACIE VI oỡ dot w sederata edd dotw I83b won I

on at szeds bus satxe .meds not " Jnwoo0s" od ba90 TOTIS NB telold rola mi acceb bus 19onsister gnow omoa 918 079rit

to ear old be, orenibtü ax.engia Lelol110 ore bra sotie od Al ponentþï0 winevšďů od ml "qlla"s

ono bas sonsaibro qmaja ɔdi ni owd two bean foq asd rexwaser. ed.

add or a .eonsatbro galjøi et al Isaigiro ald bontafque oval I a0

Iseb o bad I 27.q8q To sitg et al ʊrebloos yd betooltevo zaw ojunta gaussed groтw n od ɔves IIida b6INOW J1 Ii bocning I bad nevo Jud od mwerb (on new not: bas ,000ta berodis arod oved aegit efic

.HONJ

-Bodent Istevea or noitnotsB (WST) Asri axtov olduq to ToJ59TIT 3. qaergli gnorw bas bajjimo abrow,eonantb10 f>isen allert odd at astom

gagi. .com era omoa juf stewone disq Jaom MÍJ 101 Drs smaloljino sil asw anteq letosque tot Xhow nemud to vl·lNHIST Bd wedia, sexisJSİN Betis Jon ti owd di baOT FZS10 .TI,Jdghĩ consaibro aidd seg of necies

■Romij B ICW red .ATOTI☺ [[ka ons eronj Jeyaomt:,3 Juoda I bas Jadj bǝJJISOI »* O VIJB0T al ri broj ty Lob og ajrombrems to 2380 I new anob son asw won anob mɔɔr est dotw notJsoltitev Istoitto ed

bus 2008 otols (Is al bas,azOTTO Odu O18. ozolu wa .11 Tot bexas

Jata Ilw Dra ybset 18w I betoveoalb of ga ilokw anedito yna al JI bre +

ald broyal,sofacalm eit ojsaimble of a bus Jatıqết đủ vonb va asw .00 03 offisaoqui eg os ameoa ti

I now come to the question of the extra work, which seems to have 48 bear completely misunderstood. And first I may say generally with regard

to it that if there has been a little less suspicion, a little less

reticence, and a greater desire to get at the truth of the question

defini

and to understand my point of view,' there would have bear no difficulty

in adjusting it. I have all along carefully refrained from making a

definite claim until I was forced to by the non-possumus attitude of

the Government; when I first mooted it to Sir F. Lugerd, long before

the work had attained the proportions to which it subsequently attained,

I realised the delicacy of the question, but I anticipated that the

Council would deal with it as an honourable man deals with such a ques-

tion, and would themselves propose the proper solution of it. If a

man in the ordinary affairs of life gets more from his bargain with a

workman than he ever anticipated, and the workman gives more than he

ever anticipated, the honourable man acknowledges it and recompenses

the workman accordingly. The law deals with the question by recogni-

sing the right of the workman in a quantum meruit. I hardly believed

that it would be necessary to go further. The additional work was

done and was accepted, inevitable, when there was no possibility of

stopping, when we all had come to acknowledge that we had started on

plain an almost limitless pinne of reforming the laws, and that it was abs0-

lutely necessary to go on. I have intimated over and over again that I

was quite ready to submit the question to any unofficial gentlemen

and to accept their decision. The gentlemen I have always had in my

stand mind were Sir Kai Hokai and Mr Pollock. They at least would underatná

what K was taling about whereas I felt that I might write reams with-

out making an official with no knowledge of legal work begin to under-

stand the question; he would never get # away from the point that a

contract having been entered into must be carried out, which has noth- ing to do with the present question. I imagine that Sir F. Lugard felt this himself, for he wrote me that the Council had decided that when

the whole work was finished the Council would consider the question "fairly", and he also acknowldged that the work which had been done far exceeded what he had ever anticipated. The Council's present idea

of"fairness" is to reject the claim altogether.

#

I really do not know how to make the preliminary point clear in wri- ting, but I must try, because the Government will not talk it over. Reading the proofs for simple revision such as was at first contempla-

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.